🩺 Take the FREE Church Health Audit

Take a few minutes to find out how healthy and aligned your ministry really is. The free Church Health Audit gives you an honest snapshot and clear next steps to get your team in sync.

If I walked into your church this Sunday and asked ten of your most faithful people one simple question — "How does somebody go from walking in these doors for the first time to becoming a mature follower of Jesus who's making other disciples?" — what would they say? I'd probably get ten different answers. Some of them would point to a class. Some would point to a small group. Some would just kind of wave their hand toward the calendar and say, "You know… you get plugged in."

And that right there is the problem.

It's not that you don't care about discipleship. You care deeply. It's not that you're not doing anything — you're doing everything. You've got classes and groups and studies and serve teams and a men's breakfast and a women's night and three different Bible reading plans floating around. You are busy. Your people are busy.

But busy isn't the same as maturing. And a pile of programs isn't the same as a pathway.

The One Command We Can't Afford to Get Fuzzy On

Before we get practical, let's plant our feet on the ground Jesus gave us. Listen to what he says in Matthew 28:

Did you catch the main verb? We love to say "Go." We put "Go" on the T-shirts. But "go" isn't actually the command. In the original, "go" is a participle — it assumes you're already on the move. The command, the one imperative Jesus hangs the whole thing on, is make disciples.

Make disciples.

Not draw crowds. Not fill seats. Not run programs. Make disciples. And then, so there's no confusion about what that even means, Paul hands Timothy the finish line:

That word — mature — is the target. The goal of everything you're doing on a Sunday and everything you're doing in between Sundays is a person who looks more like Jesus this year than they did last year. And here's the part that raises the bar even higher: a mature disciple doesn't just grow. A mature disciple reproduces. Paul told Timothy to take what he'd learned and "commit to faithful men who will be able to teach others also" (2 Timothy 2:2, CSB). Disciples who make disciples. That's the win. That's always been the win.

So here's the honest question: does your church have a clear, simple, repeatable way to move a person toward that? Or do you just have a bunch of good things happening that you're hoping adds up to it?

What a Discipleship Pathway Actually Is

Let's define our terms, because this is where a lot of churches get tangled up.

A discipleship pathway is your strategy — the "how" of your church. It's the intentional, sequenced, memorable set of steps that moves a person from first-time guest to mature, multiplying disciple. It's not a program. It's not one more thing to add to the calendar. It's the through-line that gives all your programs a direction.

Think of it like this. A program is a room. A pathway is the hallway that connects the rooms and tells people which door to walk through next. Most churches have built a beautiful house full of rooms — and forgot to build the hallways. So people wander. They show up, they like it, they mean to get more connected… and then eighteen months later they're still standing in the lobby, still a spectator, and nobody ever handed them the next step.

Here's the truth: people do not drift into maturity. They drift out of it. Your job as a leader is to hand them clarity. A pathway is just clarity you can hand somebody.

The 6 Marks of a Pathway That Actually Works

I've looked at a lot of these — the ones that work and the ones that just look good on a graphic. The effective ones share six marks. Run your own church through these honestly.

1. It's clear. Everybody can name it. Your greeter, your youth intern, your eighty-year-old in the third row — they can all say it the same way. If it takes a paragraph to explain, it's not a pathway, it's a policy. Clarity is the whole game.

2. It's simple. The enemy of simple is complicated, and complicated is the enemy of movement. The best pathways I've seen have three or four steps. Not eleven. You should be able to put it on a napkin. If you can't sketch it in ten seconds for a guy at a coffee shop, your people can't reproduce it — and if they can't reproduce it, it's not making disciples, it's just keeping you busy.

3. It's sequenced. There's a first step and a next step. A pathway assumes movement — from where somebody is, to where God wants them to be. A guest has a next step. A new believer has a next step. A growing member has a next step. A pathway makes sure nobody ever has to guess, "Okay… now what?"

4. It measures the right win. Here's where a lot of us have to repent a little. We count attendance. We count offering. Those are easy to count, so those are what we celebrate. But a pathway measures movement — how many people took the next step this quarter, not just how many people showed up. Attendance tells you who's in the room. It doesn't tell you who's growing. Change what you count, and you'll change what you chase.

5. It's relational at the core. Hear me on this one: a pathway is not a substitute for a person. You can build the cleanest four-step graphic in the county and still not make a single disciple, because disciples are made in relationship — Jesus with twelve, Paul with Timothy, an older believer across the table from a younger one. The pathway isn't the discipleship. It's the structure that makes room for it. The Holy Spirit and real relationships are what actually grow a person up in Christ.

6. It aims at multiplication. The last step of a healthy pathway isn't "mature." It's "now go make one." If your pathway ends with a comfortable, well-fed, growing Christian who never reproduces, you've built a really nice spiritual cul-de-sac. The pathway has to point people back out the door — to serve, to lead, to disciple somebody else. Addition fills a room. Multiplication fills a movement.

How to Build Yours — On One Page, This Month

Alright. Practical time, because a principle you can't act on is just a nice feeling. Here's how to actually build this. You can start today, and you can get the first draft onto a single page.

Step 1 — Map the journey in stages. Get your team in a room and answer one question: what are the actual stages a person moves through here? Don't overthink it. Most churches land on something like: Guest → Connected → Growing → Serving → Multiplying. Name yours in your own words. The stages are the skeleton of everything else.

Step 2 — Define ONE clear next step for each stage. This is the heart of it. For every stage, what is the single, obvious, "if you do nothing else, do this" next step? A guest's next step might be a two-week welcome gathering. A connected person's next step might be joining a group. A growing person's next step might be serving on a team. One step per stage. Not a menu of twelve options — one. When you give people a menu, they order nothing. When you give them a next step, they take it.

Step 3 — Prune what doesn't move people. Now look at everything on your calendar and ask the hard question: does this program actually move somebody along the pathway, or does it just fill a square and eat volunteers? Some of your programs are good rooms with no door into the hallway. Sometimes the key to growth isn't something you start — it's something you stop. You can't manufacture more volunteers or more money. You can only point what you've got in the right direction. So give your pathway an unfair advantage. Pour your best people, your best communication, and your best energy into the handful of things that actually make disciples, and let the rest go.

Step 4 — Make it visible and repeatable. Put it on the wall. Put it in the bulletin. Preach it. Say it from the stage until your people are mouthing it along with you. The clearer your pathway, the more likely your people are to share it — and a pathway your people can repeat is a pathway that can grow beyond you. If discipleship lives only in your head, it dies when you're on vacation.

Step 5 — Measure movement and celebrate it. Pick your number. How many people moved to the next step this quarter? Put it in front of your team every month. And when somebody moves — when a guest joins a group, when a member gets baptized, when a growing believer starts leading — celebrate it out loud. What you celebrate, you get more of. Tell the stories. Movement is contagious.

That's the whole build. Five steps. One page. You could have a rough draft by your next staff meeting.

"But Isn't Discipleship the Spirit's Work?"

I know somebody's thinking it, so let's just say it out loud: "Ryan, you can't systematize the Holy Spirit. Discipleship is a work of God. You're turning a mystery into a flowchart."

Hear me — you're right that it's the Spirit's work. Growth is a gift. No pathway ever regenerated a single heart, and it never will. But watch this. Sanctification is both a divine work and a human responsibility. God empowers; we still have to cooperate. Paul says it in the very next breath after "present everyone mature" — "I labor for this, striving with his strength that works powerfully in me" (Colossians 1:29, CSB). See the both/and? His strength. Paul's striving. At the same time.

A pathway doesn't replace the Spirit. A pathway is just how stewardship shows up. Proverbs says the horse is made ready for the day of battle, but victory belongs to the Lord. So you build the plan, you clarify the steps, you do the faithful, unglamorous work of leadership — and then you trust God to do what only God can do. Don't blame the Spirit for what was really a lack of prayerful planning. And don't worship the plan as if it could do the Spirit's job. Build the structure. Trust the Spirit.

One More Thing Before You Go

I want to talk to the leader who just read all that and feels the weight of it — who's looking at a calendar full of good things and quietly realizing there's no hallway connecting any of them.

Most of us built the house one good room at a time, with the best of intentions, and never stopped long enough to draw the hallways. That's not negligence. That's just what happens when you love people and say yes to good things for a decade.

But you get to fix this. And here's the good news: you don't have to launch anything new to do it. You probably already have most of the rooms. You just need to build the hallway — to get clear, get simple, and hand your people a next step. That's not a program you can't afford. That's clarity, and clarity is mostly free.

So this week, get your team in a room. Draw the stages. Name the next steps. Start pointing everything you've already got in one direction. Do that, and you'll be amazed how much movement was waiting on the other side of a little clarity.

Make disciples. It's still the assignment. And he's still with you, "always, to the end of the age."

Now go build the pathway.

🔔 Don't Start From Scratch

Checkout our growing library of done-for-you resources and Kits. Each Kit is designed to be plug-and-play and saves your team hours each week. From hiring and leadership to volunteers and discipleship -- there's a Kit ready for you to download and implement this week.